Sure I've mentioned this before but back to reexamine obvious points about life...
We take a cell from the body of multicellular organism and keep it in a petri-dish. Is this cell alive?
It seems to be accepted that "Life" involves the following 7 things: respire, feed, excrete, grow, move, sensitivity, reproduce.
Well unless it is an extremely specialised cell then it probably still has the capability to do these 7 things.
But if each cell is "alive" then is the organism living that is made from them? i.e. a repeating point in this blog: is the organism anything other than the cells that comprise it?
The note I made to myself when a student inspired this was: is life within the cells or between the cells?
They do not classify viruses as living because they don't fulfill the characteristics: that is viruses taken separate from the machinary of a cell. But in association with a cell they become involved with these essential characteristics albeit temporarily. So what of commensal organisms that co-exist like lichens or interdependent organisms like predator and prey or parasitoids? By themselves they perform the characteristics only in so far as they have items upon which to feed. A propensity to feed is nothing without food. So to fulfill feeding organisms depend upon environment and community. Can a "living thing" be isolated on the petri dish and the "Life" studied as somehow being "contained" within its cell walls or epithelium. Can any of these characteristics arise within the membrane? Or is it between the membrane and the environment that it occurs?
This is a perennial problem in thought being applied to "Life".
A search for happiness in poverty. Happiness with personal loss, and a challenge to the wisdom of economic growth and environmental exploitation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
"The Jewish Fallacy" OR "The Inauthenticity of the West"
I initially thought to start up a discussion to formalise what I was going to name the "Jewish Fallacy" and I'm sure there is ...
-
The classic antimony is between : (1) action that is chosen freely and (2) action that comes about through physical causation. To date no ...
-
Well that was quite interesting ChatGPT can't really "think" of anything to detract from the argument that Jews have no clai...
-
There are few people in England I meet these days who do not think we are being ruled by an non-democratic elite. The question is just who t...
No comments:
Post a Comment