The logic flaw at the heart of the Jewish problem

The Jewish problem. When you argue with ChatGPT this is what you get. It switches between Jews being ethnic and Jews being Religious and it can't make its mind up. HAL9000 or Ash territory. What it can't work out is that the ethnicity of Jews are the Israelites from Israel and the rest of the Jewish religion is made of other people especially Russians. When Simon Schama or Rachel Riley calls themselves Jewish they are obviously not an Israelite like Claudia Winkleman. Seems ChatGPT can't handle the logic above, and neither can the UN, NAZIs or UK Government.

Israelites are from Israel; Jews are not from Israel! It's a Q->P logic error (also called Affirming the consequent). Really realising that logic errors lie behind everything (thank you ChatGPT for that). This is current Jewish logic:

(1) Israelites are from Israel (2) People from Israel have a Right to Return (3) Some Jews are Israelites (4) Therefore Jews have a Right to Return

The vast majority of Jews do not have a Right to "Return" because they were never there! They say around 10,000 people convert to Judaism each year. Obviously this figure has increased with world population, but assuming it is linear increase in conversion then over 1000 years that is 10/2 million = 5 million Jews who have never been anywhere near the Middle East. Current estimates of Jewish populations is 15.7 million so at very least 1 in 3 Jews is definitely not Israelite. It is nonsense.

And they have it back to front. Israel was not created to protect Jews, that is clearly a distortion. If this was true then anywhere would do. No Israel is a belief in a return to a mythological Kingdom just as English could return to Avalon or Germans to the 1st Reich. This belief came first. And arguably this belief is what sets Jews against other people which leads them down the road they have gone.

Here for example is the diagram for Christians. Obviously some Israelites became Christians and I some still are! By current Jewish logic then: (1) Israelites are from Israel (2) People from Israel have a Right to Return (3) Some Christians are Israelites (4) Therefore Christians have a Right to Return